Similarity percentage regulation
What criteria should be considered to develop institutional policies of similarity in research works
5 replies
-
DENNIS Not entirely sure what you are asking here, please can you give me a little more information.
-
I though an institution can come up with a percentage which is acceptable and also impower the tutors to work out the semilaries for originality improvement
-
Different schools, different policy there is no UNIVERSALLY ACCEPTED similarity index.
In some universities, they penalize students who >70% similarity but in the University where I am employed we allow 15% similarity while university does it at 10%. I tend to subscribe to turn-it-in's dictum that the best way to "deter plagiarism is turn plagiarism into teachable moments." -
We don't even have an institutional policy. It's typically at the department level but even that isn't consistent.
-
I argue strongly against a "magic number" rather the student & marker should look at what is similar. (note: Similar NOT plagiarised) For example, you may have a lot of frequently used phrases (e.g. discussing how a survey was carried out - there are only so many ways of describing it).
If a student has 30% of their essay made up of those sort of phrases - e.g . lots of <2% similar fragments), then that's probably a very different scenario from a student who's got 20% similar which is made of up 1 whole page identical to another source in a 5 page essay.However, what if there's a 2% similar chunk - but that 2% is the conclusion of an essay - and on reading, the marker realises they found a great conclusion - so wrote the essay to fit ...